Monday, September 14, 2026

​State Oppression Is a Feature, Not a Bug

Governments are working exactly as their controllers intend them to work.


The governmental system as it now exists practically everywhere on earth is designed for the purpose of giving its controllers the power to oppress, abuse, and plunder other people. It's doing so is not a malfunction, not a foul-up, not a deviation from its central tendency. Governments as we know them are not created by accident. They are created with great deliberation by people willing to murder and rob others in order to control a society, or at least as much of a society as necessary for the attainment of their purposes.


All notions of government to the contrary are fairy tales or propaganda aimed at bamboozling the victims. People keep saying that "the true purpose of government" is to protect people's lives, liberties, and property, but it's simply not true. If it were, governments would be nothing like what we see them to be now and to have been for thousands of years. Rulers constantly make excuses and offer rationales for their destructive actions and claim credit for benefits that are none of their doing, but as Matthew 7:16 alerts us, "Ye shall know them by their fruits. Do men gather grapes of thorns, or figs of thistles?"

--
Source: Robert Higgs

Thursday, September 10, 2026

Licensing Reframes Rights as Privileges

One of the most interesting things about licensing laws is how often they’re framed as “protection” while simultaneously functioning as barriers to entry, revenue generators, and control mechanisms. In many cases, peaceful people are fully capable of offering services voluntarily, yet governments step in and declare that you now need official permission, fees, paperwork, inspections, renewals, mandatory courses, and regulatory approval before you’re allowed to engage in work that harms nobody.

The strange part is that society rarely applies this logic consistently. People understand that voluntary reputation, reviews, certifications, referrals, competition, contracts, insurance, and consumer choice can regulate quality in countless industries already. Yet the moment government licensing enters the conversation, many suddenly assume freedom itself becomes dangerous unless bureaucrats supervise it.

Obviously there are some areas where standards and safety matter, especially when direct physical harm is involved. But licensing systems frequently expand far beyond genuine safety concerns and start protecting established interests from competition instead. Entire professions become artificially restricted, driving up prices and making it harder for ordinary people to earn a living.

A lot of people don’t realize how much of modern life operates on the assumption that you need political approval to peacefully work, build, sell, transport, modify, operate, or create things that would otherwise simply be voluntary interactions between consenting adults. Once you start noticing it, you see it everywhere.

Statism normalizes the idea that rights become conditional upon state permission. Freedom increasingly gets reframed as a privilege temporarily granted by authorities instead of something people naturally possess by default.

--
Originally a Facebook post by Chris Snyder

Sunday, September 6, 2026

Peaceful Migration Is Not a Crime

Why do so many people have so much trouble concentrating on one thing? If it is wrong, as I maintain, for people -- even people who style themselves "the government" -- to initiate or threaten to initiate violent action against peaceful people simply because they have crossed a so-called national border without official approval, then such wrongful action should stop, and decent people should oppose its continuation.

It is a red herring to raise questions about (1) crimes the migrants might commit, (2) welfare benefits they might collect, (3) politicians, parties, and causes they might ultimately support at the polls, and (4) cultural changes they might bring about. Apart from the great uncertainty that surrounds these possible future events, they are separate issues -- issues that relate to all residents of the country, not only to those who came into the country from elsewhere. The existence of possible problems associated with crime, welfare, voting, and cultural change is not a valid excuse for continuation of the violence initiated or threatened by the government against peaceful immigrants. The existence of possible wrongs of type B, C, D, and E is not an excuse for the continuation of Type A wrong in the here and now.

---
Robert Higgs

Saturday, September 5, 2026

Libertarianism: The logic of peaceful interaction

If there were no scarcity in the world, human conflicts would be impossible. Interpersonal conflicts are always and everywhere conflicts concerning scarce things. I want to do X with a given thing and you want to do Y with the same thing.

Because of such conflicts — and because we are able to communicate and argue with each other — we seek out norms of behavior with the purpose of avoiding these conflicts. The purpose of norms is conflict-avoidance. If we did not want to avoid conflicts, the search for norms of conduct would be senseless. We would simply fight and struggle.

Absent a perfect harmony of all interests, conflicts regarding scarce resources can only be avoided if all scarce resources are assigned as private, exclusive property to some specified individual. Only then can I act independently, with my own things, from you, with your own things, without you and me coming into conflict.

But who owns what scarce resource as his private property and who does not? First: Each person owns his physical body that only he and no one else controls directly (I can control your body only in-directly, by first directly controlling my body, and vice versa) and that only he directly controls also in particular when discussing and arguing the question at hand. Otherwise, if body-ownership were assigned to some indirect body-controller, conflict would become unavoidable as the direct body-controller cannot give up his direct control over his body as long as he is alive; and in particular, otherwise it would be impossible that any two persons, as the contenders in any property dispute, could ever argue and debate the question whose will is to prevail, since arguing and debating presupposes that both, the proponent and the opponent, have exclusive control over their respective bodies and so come to the correct judgment on their own, without a fight (in a conflict-free form of interaction).

And second, as for scarce resources that can be controlled only indirectly (that must be appropriated with our own nature-given, i.e., un-appropriated, body): Exclusive control (property) is acquired by and assigned to that person, who appropriated the resource in question first or who acquired it through voluntary (conflict-free) exchange from its previous owner. For only the first appropriator of a resource (and all later owners connected to him through a chain of voluntary exchanges) can possibly acquire and gain control over it without conflict, i.e., peacefully. Otherwise, if exclusive control is assigned instead to latecomers, conflict is not avoided but contrary to the very purpose of norms made unavoidable and permanent.

Let me emphasize that I consider this theory as essentially irrefutable, as a priori true. In my estimation this theory represents one of the greatest — if not the greatest — achievement of social thought. It formulates and codifies the immutable ground rules for all people, everywhere, who wish to live together in peace.


---
Source:
Hans-Hermann Hoppe, A Realistic Libertarianism

Thursday, November 27, 2025

"But true Socialism has never been tried" | Robert Higgs

Robert Higgs on the argument that 'true socialism has never been tried' :

"Of course, but the accusation is not sound. Not only has every actually-implemented socialist setup been a disaster, but socialism is intrinsically flawed for reasons spelled out by Mises and Hayek. A true market system is something we know from sound theory can work well, whereas a true socialist system is something we know from sound theory cannot work well. Even the corrupted market systems actually adopted have vastly outperformed the socialist systems actually adopted. "Real" socialism would be a disaster just as much as, if not more than, half-assed socialism like that of the USSR, China, and other places."

Democracy as Participatory Fascism

Astute socialists (if that’s not an oxymoron) opt for participatory fascism, not outright socialism, in practice.

They know that outright socialism—the nationalization and central control of all the major means of production—is a ruinous system. By opting for participatory fascism, they can get the bulk of what they seek, by means of pervasive regulation, heavy taxation, and floods of government spending, while allowing the fettered capitalists enough room for maneuver that they keep the economy from going straight to hell.

Moreover, when anything goes wrong—and it will—they can blame the problem on capitalism, the fraudulently so-called free-market economy that remains in hobbled operation.

- Robert Higgs

The Private Production of Defense


Hans Hoppe takes on the most difficult subject in economic and political theory: the provision of security. He argues that the service is better provided by free markets than government, while addressing a hundred counter-arguments. Here we have an important updating of an argument rarely made even in the libertarian tradition.

"Without the erroneous public perception and judgment of the state as just and necessary and without the public’s voluntary cooperation, even the seemingly most powerful government would implode and its powers evaporate. Thus liberated, we would regain our right to self-defense and be able to turn to freed and unregulated insurance agencies for efficient professional assistance in all matters of protection and conflict resolution." —Hans-Hermann Hoppe

Download: PDF | EPUB

Wednesday, November 26, 2025

Low Wage Helps Low-Skilled Workers

"There is no inherent reason why low-skilled or high-risk employees are any less employable than high-skilled, low-risk employees. Someone who is five times as valuable to an employer is no more or less employable than someone who is one-fifth as valuable, WHEN THE PAY DIFFERENCES REFLECT THEIR DIFFERENCES IN BENEFITS TO THE EMPLOYER.

This is MORE THAN A THEORETICAL POINT. Historically, lower skill levels did not prevent black males from having labor force participation rates higher than that of white males for every US Census from 1890 through 1930. Since then, the general growth of wage-fixing arrangements: minimum wage laws, labor unions, civil service pay scales, etc. has reversed that and made more and more blacks unemployable despite their rising levels of education and skills: absolutely and relative to whites."

"In short, no one is employable or unemployable absolutely, BUT ONLY RELATIVE TO A GIVEN PAY SCALE."

"Workers compete against other workers (not employers) to find jobs and get the highest wages. Employers compete against other employers to find the best workers. In other words, low-skilled workers compete against high-skilled workers in the labor market. LOW-SKILLED WORKERS WHO WOULD BE EMPLOYABLE AT A LOW WAGE BECOME UNEMPLOYABLE AT AN ARTIFICIALLY HIGHER WAGE. And that explains the perverse cruelty of minimum wage laws: it inflicts the greatest harm on the very workers it is allegedly designed to help."

https://www.aei.org/economics/thomas-sowell-on-the-cruelty-of-minimum-wage-laws/


Sunday, November 17, 2019

Herd mentality: A Psychological Tactic in Politics

Excerpted from:
Against the State: An Interview with Lew Rockwell

QUESTION: Government is theater. Would you agree?
LEW ROCKWELL: Yeah, a bloody theater, a terrible theater, but it is a theater, and they know it. They know this is how to appease the people.
QUESTION: Two psychologists have studied the use of words by politicians in recent years. The most used word now by politicians in America is the word “we.” The use of this word actually gets people to form into a group where essentially they stop thinking. That is connected to the theater concept of controlling people, and I guarantee you that the government hires behaviorists and psychologists, and they study how to manipulate people. What do you think about that?
LEW ROCKWELL: I remember one of the critics of the Nazis saying that it is an indication of totalitarianism when politicians refer to “our children.” They are not your children. They are God’s children, and they are the parents’ children. They are not the government’s children, but the government, of course, feels they are and they want to shape them. They want to mold them and they want parents to have less and less to do with it. They want them in the public schools from 6 to 6, eating all their meals there and that sort of thing. You know they are not that kind of villain, but they are, in fact, villains. Even if they seem like nice, decent people, they are actually not.
I was once in politics myself before going straight, and I can tell you they are not good people. I encountered only one man whom I thought was thoroughly good, and I had the honor of working for him eventually, and that was Ron Paul, and also the only person in politics I have ever encountered who did not have the lust to rule, the lust to dominate. Ron Paul doesn’t have that, so he was a very odd bird in politics. For him, politics was an educational mission, but most of them want to dominate. Again, most of us are not interested in running the next door neighbor’s family. We don’t want to run the next town. We don’t want to run the next country. We have enough to do with our own families, mowing our lawn, doing our job, earning enough money, and so forth, that is what we want to do. But there are people who want to run the family next door. They want to run the next town. They want to run the world.
QUESTION: So they become government officials.
LEW ROCKWELL: They go into politics.

Friday, November 15, 2019

Freedom: Because It Works or Because It’s Right? | Robert Higgs

December 27, 2012

Libertarians divide into two broad classes: those who espouse a free society because it gives better results than an unfree society, and those who espouse a free society because they believe that it is wrong to deny or suppress a person’s right to be free (unless, of course, that person is suppressing the equal right of others to be free). “Consequentialists versus deontologists” is the oft-encountered labeling of this difference. It is unfortunate that so much energy has been devoted to infighting between these two groups.

Free Trade is Freedom | Robert Higgs

The case for free international trade is simply the case for freedom in general. Those who claim that conditions can be improved by restrictions, taxes, subsidies, and bans of international buying and selling are saying either that they know better than every other person what transactions will provide a net benefit to that person or that they have a right to override the buying and selling choices that all other individuals regard as in their best interest. In short, trade restrictionists of all stripes, including so-called protectionists, rest their case on either proposterous claims about what they know or outrageous presumptions of a right to pester and punish peaceful people for the sake of particular special interests who seek to pick their fellows' pockets.

- Robert Higgs

Love Is The Answer | Robert Higgs

Many people are wicked and violent, and these are the ones with a comparative advantage in taking control of government as we know it. Given this reality, one might expect that life everywhere would tend toward an equilibrium like the Hobbsian scenario: poor, nasty, brutish, and short, even if not solitary.

Yet historically such has not been the case always and everywhere. Over substantial areas of the world, conditions have become much better in terms of economic well-being, life expectancy, health, and even social harmony. How has this progress been possible?

The answer most economic historians now advance is that certain institutions, especially relatively secure private property rights and respect for entrepreneurship and private contracting, were put in place, prompting entrepreneurs of many sorts to devise productivity-enhancing innovations and thereby to make possible great material gains for the average person, even those outside the ruling circles.

At a deeper level, however, it is important to recognize that in nearly all societies, love keeps breaking through: love of truth, love of beauty, love of goodness and kindness toward our fellows. To these breakthroughs we owe much of what has been achieved throughout history. Wickedness produces slavery, oppression, and plunder. Love throws a benign wrench in the wheels of wickedness. Before the great institutional advances could be put in place, love had to clear a space for them.

The cliche tells us that love is the answer. However trite it may be, it is also true.

- Robert Higgs

Democracy results in Tryanny not Freedom | Robert Higgs

Can democracy give us freedom?

"Democracy, to the extent that it operates according to the principle of majority rule, must result in tyranny, because that's what most people want. Libertarians often say that most people want freedom, but my observations and study of history do not accord with this claim.

Most people want freedom for themselves, but not for others. They want personal freedom but favor government suppression of the freedoms of people they dislike or fear for whatever reason. For most people tribalism, however understood by the members of a tribe, trumps living in a free society.

Arguing that free societies are more prosperous or otherwise successful will not persuade most people. They are prepared to wreak death and destruction on their perceived enemies, foreign and domestic, even at considerable economic sacrifice."

- Robert Higgs

Thursday, November 7, 2019

An Action Plan for Anarcho-Capitalists - Hoppe on peacefully opposing the state.

How to Fight the Modern State
By Hans-Hermann Hoppe
Mises.org
August 17, 2013

In this 1997 speech by Hans-Hermann Hoppe, now available as an ebook from the Mises Institute under the title What Must Be Done, Hoppe presents a plan of action for anarcho-capitalists against the modern state.

Hoppe begins by examining the nature of the state as “a monopolist of defense and the provision and enforcement of law and order.” Like all state-mandated monopolies, the monopoly of law enforcement also leads to higher prices and lower quality of services. Why is this state of affairs tolerated? The modern democratic states, much more than the monarchies and princely estates of old, are seen as moral and necessary despite ample evidence to the contrary.

In this initial analysis, we find much of what Hoppe eventually expanded into his 2001 book Democracy: The God that Failed, which systematically dismantled modern arguments in favor of the democratic state.

In the final portion of his speech, Hoppe turns to discussing how a modern partisan of liberty might act to counter the march of centralization and the destruction of property, culture, learning, and natural social hierarchies.

Argumentation Ethics Condensed - by Stephen Kinsella

Originally post:
http://www.stephankinsella.com/2013/08/argumentation-ethics-condensed/


"The mere fact that an individual argues presupposes that he owns himself and has a right to his own life and property. This provides a basis for libertarian theory radically different from both natural rights theory and utilitarianism."

"Think of it this way. You don’t care about all this if people are leaving you alone. You just go about your business. But if there is a dispute over your body—say someone wants to rape you or enslave you. Then either they are willing to try to justify it, or not. If not, then they are just criminals and you have to deal with them with force or whatever. If they try to justify then they have to do so in a peaceful context. And remember: all justification is necessarily argumentative justification. That means any conceivable justification, that is, any possible norm that could conceivably be justified, has to be compatible with the norms of argumentation. And those include: peace; the presumption that there is value to cooperation; the presumption that it is desirable that people have the ability to control their own bodies (not only to argue during the argument, but to have survived in the world to the point of making the argument, which requires (unmolested) use of scarce means; etc.

The point is that you can never justify a socialist or criminal ethic. How could you do so? You would have to make an argument, in the course of a peaceful argumentation, that peace is bad. This cannot be done. It is a contradiction. So if you want to commit aggression, you either have to just do it and give up on the idea that you can justify it; or, if you try to justify it, you have to recognize that it cannot be done. By examining the structure of this from the outside, we can recognize that no socialist ethic can ever, in practice, be argumentatively justified.

And to say you do not own yourself outside of argument, is simply to say that some form of socialism is justified. How can two supposedly civilized, mutually-rights-respecting, peace-desiring people (in an argument) ever argue that it’s okay to hit people who have done nothing wrong? If you make that argument, then you have no grounds for refusing to coerce the other guy into accepting your argument—which is contrary to the nature of argumentation which presupposes that each side has the right to disagree with the other and is not being coerced."

Wednesday, October 30, 2019

Murray Rothbard Versus the Koch Libertarians (Cato Institute)

October 18, 2017



The following is an overview and summary, with little contribution of my own, of David Gordon’s three part series (part 1, part 2, part 3) on the relationship that Murray Rothbard had with the Koch Brothers. To understand the libertarian movement is immensely beneficial for the libertarian at all stages of development. It teaches the nuances in theory and strategy that have developed over the years and it explains where the present state of the liberty movement came from. The Gordon essay is classic Gordon. Extremely helpful, packed full of incredible detail, and uses the past struggles of Rothbard to explain current themes in the liberty movement. 

The only problem, of course, is that it is long: three essays. I have tried hard to make the following overview engaging, short, and complete; and of course, true to Gordon’s telling of the story. Murray Rothbard was the founder of the modern libertarian movement, the chief developer of the theory and the synthesizer of libertarianism as an ethical-political theory with Austrianism as a value-free science of economic thought. His story needs to be told; not just because of what happened to him –for old wounds can and do heal– but because it explains why and how libertarianism as a movement is not just a uniform thing. There are factions. There are lessons. There are very good reasons why the libertarianism of mainstream approval is not the Rothbardianism of the 1970s, 80s, and 90s.

Something happened. Here is the story.

Tuesday, October 22, 2019

Why Mises? (and not Hayek) - by Hans-Hermann Hoppe

Let me begin with a quote from an article that my old friend Ralph Raico wrote some 15 years ago:
Ludwig von Mises and F. A. Hayek are widely considered the most eminent classical liberal thinkers of this century. They are also the two best known Austrian economists. They were great scholars and great men. I was lucky to have them both as my teachers.… Yet it is clear that the world treats them very differently. Mises was denied the Nobel Prize for economics, which Hayek won the year after Mises's death. Hayek is occasionally anthologized and read in college courses, when a spokesman for free enterprise absolutely cannot be avoided; Mises is virtually unknown in American academia. Even among organizations that support the free market in a general way, it is Hayek who is honored and invoked, while Mises is ignored or pushed into the background.
I want to speculate — and present a thesis — why this is so and explain why I — and I take it most of us here — take a very different view. Why I (and presumably you) are Misesians and not Hayekians.

Observations on Hayek’s Plan by Mises

Abstract: This memorandum was written at the request of Henry Hazlitt to provide Mises’s comments on and concerns about F.A. Hayek’s initial proposals for what became the Mont Pèlerin Society. Mises stresses that those who favor liberty and freedom and oppose totalitarianism must also oppose interventionism. The memo argues that those who fought and lost against the rising tide of totalitarianism at the turn of the 20th Century lost their battles because they settled for middle-of-the-road policies that conceded considerable ground to the socialists. The weak point in Professor Hayek’s plan is that it relies upon the cooperation of many men who are today’s middle-of-the-roaders. As interventionists, they may not be the hoped-for intellectual pioneers to inspire people to build a freer world.




Monday, October 14, 2019

Karachi as a province

S. Akbar Zaidi
January 11, 2014

THERE is little disagreement on the suggestion that Pakistan needs many more provinces than the existing four (five, if one includes Gilgit-Baltistan). From aspects of political economy to being able to better administer smaller units, many arguments support the idea of numerous new provinces.



The argument that more provinces would break Punjab’s hegemony over the rest of Pakistan and parts of what currently constitute Punjab itself are equally valid. A Seraiki and Hazara suba are a key requirement for the people of those regions. It has been suggested that the older 12 divisions of Pakistan, with modifications, should become provinces or autonomous administrative units. One of them was Karachi Division.

The issue of making Karachi a province is laced with emotion. Any such demand is seen as incendiary and challenges the supposed integrity of the Pakistani nation-state. Karachi’s political economy must be studied to consider whether a city of 20 million could exist as a province or even as an independent territory.

Sunday, October 13, 2019

Is PDA a crime in Pakistan?

Young couples, know your rights the next time you're stopped by a cop



KARACHI: As evening falls in Karachi, Ahmed* and his girlfriend Manahil* head out on a dinner date. This wasn’t just any date, the 24-year-old wanted to surprise his girlfriend with the news that his family had agreed to their marriage. But fate had another surprise in store for them: a stark reminder of the fact that they live in Pakistan, where love costs a thing or two.

On the way back from dinner, Ahmed took a detour and stopped his car on the service road. The couple shared a kiss. “It was nothing more than that,” says Manahil. “But before we knew it, two uniformed law enforcers on a bike came out of nowhere and one put his pistol on the window,” she recalls.

Ahmed opened the door and stepped out of the car, only to be hit by the personnel on his head. “They took my partner away and took away our mobile phones and wallets,” she says.

The policemen continued to harass the young couple for almost 20 minutes. They threatened them with jail time and said they would only be released if their parents came to the police station. “I started crying. They even called me a slut,” Manahil recounts. “They took Ahmed to the nearest ATM and let us go only after taking a total Rs17,000 from us.”